Retaliation in the workplace isn’t just a betrayal of professional trust, it’s also illegal. For New York employees, retaliation can take many forms, from subtle exclusion and demotion to outright termination. Knowledge of what happens after retaliation and how the legal process unfolds is critical to protecting your rights, career, and dignity.
Whether you’re facing retaliation for reporting discrimination, taking family leave, filing a wage complaint, or standing up for a co-worker, New York law is on your side, provided you take the right steps. At Levine & Blit, our experienced employment retaliation attorneys in New York City have represented numerous clients in the legal process of confronting and remedying employer retaliation and helped them achieve successful outcomes.
👉Also Read: 10 Common Signs of Retaliation at Work and Your Legal Options in New York
What Constitutes Retaliation in New York?
At its core, retaliation occurs when an employer punishes an employee for engaging in a legally protected activity. Protected activities include, but are not limited to:
- Reporting employment discrimination (based on race, gender, age, disability, etc.)
- Reporting workplace discrimination resisting sexual advances or harassment refusing sexual favors
- Participating in an investigation (internal or external)
- Requesting reasonable accommodations (under ADA or NY Human Rights Law)
- Filing a complaint for unpaid wages or overtime
- Taking family or medical leave (FMLA or NY Paid Family Leave)
- Refusing to participate in illegal activities
- Whistleblowing (internal or external)
- Retaliation against job applicants
Common Examples of Retaliation by a Manager
- Sudden negative performance reviews following a complaint
- Demotion or reassignment to undesirable duties
- Isolation from meetings, opportunities, or projects
- Heightened scrutiny or micromanagement
- Pay cuts or loss of benefits
- Termination shortly after engaging in protected activity
These retaliatory actions are often subtle and disguised as legitimate business decisions. That’s why working with an experienced New York workplace retaliation claim attorney is essential for identifying patterns and establishing a causal link between your protected activity and the adverse action.
👉Also Read: 6 Warning Signs Your Boss is Retaliating
Step-by-Step Breakdown of the Legal Process After Retaliation in New York
Recognize the Retaliation and Act Promptly
The first step is to understand that what you’re experiencing may not just be unfair; it could be illegal retaliation. Time is critical: under federal law and New York law, there are strict deadlines to file a complaint. For instance:
- EEOC (federal) claims: 300 days from the retaliatory act (if state/local laws apply)
- NYS Division of Human Rights (DHR): 1 year from the retaliatory act
- Lawsuits in court (under NYCHRL): up to 3 years
Many state and federal employees make the mistake of waiting too long, assuming things will improve or not realizing the seriousness of the retaliation.
Immediate Steps to Take:
- Document everything (emails, performance reviews, comments from managers)
- Keep a timeline of events
- Retain copies of complaints or reports you submitted
- Avoid deleting texts or Slack messages related to your concerns
Consult Our NYC Workplace Retaliation Attorney
Before you confront HR or your manager, it is prudent to speak with our dedicated New York City employment retaliation attorney at Levine & Blit. Retaliation cases under the Civil Rights Act and the Fair Labor Standards Act are complex, and employers are usually prepared with legal teams trained to protect the company.
Our workplace retaliation and sexual harassment attorney will:
- Analyze your case and assess the strength of your workplace retaliation claim
- Help you preserve evidence and avoid common missteps
- Strategically plan how and when to escalate your concerns
- Determine the appropriate legal forum for filing your claim (EEOC, NYSDHR, court)
At Levine & Blit, we leave no stone unturned to find hidden evidence of management retaliation during our initial investigations. There could be patterns that a reasonable employee might overlook but are pivotal in building a strong case.
👉Also Read: Can You Challenge a Severance Agreement in NYC? Your Rights and Options
File an Internal Complaint (Optional but Strategic)
While not always necessary, filing an internal complaint with your human resources department or a compliance hotline can serve several purposes:
- It documents your concern in writing
- It gives the employer a chance to address the issue
- It shows that you followed company procedure
That said, many internal investigations are designed to protect the employer, not the employee. This is why legal guidance during this stage is invaluable. Our attorney can help you draft the internal complaint in a way that preserves your legal claims and avoids misinterpretation.
Choose the Right Legal Forum
You have multiple avenues to pursue a retaliation claim, depending on the nature of your case:
A. EEOC (Equal Employment Opportunity Commission)
- Best for retaliation related to discrimination or harassment
- Mandatory step before filing federal lawsuits
- EEOC investigates, may offer mediation, or issue a “Right to Sue” letter
B. New York State Division of Human Rights (NYSDHR)
- State-level equivalent for discrimination and retaliation
- Handles investigation, mediation, and hearings
C. NYC Commission on Human Rights
- Covers retaliation under the broad NYC Human Rights Law
- Known for employee-friendly standards and remedies
D. Filing Directly in Court
- If your retaliation relates to wage theft, whistleblower status, or you’ve already gone through an administrative agency
- Allows for broader discovery and potential jury trials
- Under the NYC Human Rights Law, you can go straight to court without administrative exhaustion
Our attorney will evaluate where you’re likely to obtain the most favorable outcome and whether to pursue multiple claims simultaneously.
Investigation and Response from the Employer
Once your claim is filed with an agency, the employer will be notified and asked to respond. This stage generally includes:
- A formal written response from the employer’s counsel
- Requests for additional information from the agency
- Interviews or depositions
- Mediation sessions (optional or required, depending on the forum)
Expect your employer to deny wrongdoing, justify their actions, or claim ignorance. Many employers will try to reframe the issue as a performance problem. This is where detailed documentation and strategic legal framing can make or break your case.
Resolution Options: Settlement, Hearing, or Lawsuit
Depending on how the process evolves, several outcomes are possible:
A. Settlement
Many retaliation cases settle before reaching trial. A favorable settlement might include:
- Monetary compensation (lost wages, emotional distress, punitive damages)
- Reinstatement or front pay
- Attorney’s fees
- Removal of negative employment records
- Non-retaliation commitments
B. Agency Determination and Hearing
If the agency finds probable cause, the case may go to an administrative hearing. The administrative judge will hear evidence and issue a decision, which may be binding.
C. Filing a Lawsuit in Civil Court
If a settlement cannot be reached or the agency process is insufficient, you can file a civil lawsuit. Civil court offers the opportunity for broader discovery, depositions, and potential jury trials.
Lawsuits under the New York City Human Rights Law (NYCHRL) are particularly powerful, offering a lower burden of proof and allowing recovery for emotional harm, punitive damages, and attorneys’ fees.
What are the Remedies for Retaliation?
If your retaliation claim succeeds either through a settlement, administrative hearing, or civil court judgment, you may be entitled to:
- Back Pay: Compensation for wages lost due to demotion, termination, or missed bonuses
- Front Pay: Future lost earnings if reinstatement is not feasible
- Emotional Distress Damages: For humiliation, anxiety, and trauma suffered
- Punitive Damages: To punish egregious employer misconduct
- Injunctive Relief: Such as reinstatement or removing retaliatory policies
- Legal Fees: Reimbursement of attorney’s fees and litigation costs
These remedies serve both to make the victim whole and to deter future employer retaliation against others.
Retaliation Protections Under NYC’s Expansive Laws
New York City offers some of the strongest worker protections in the nation. The NYC Human Rights Law (NYCHRL) is broader than federal or state law, covering:
- Independent contractors
- Interns and freelancers
- Retaliation claims even when the underlying complaint wasn’t ultimately proven, as long as it was made in good faith
This means that you do not need to win your underlying discrimination or wage case to win your retaliation claim, if you can show your complaint was made reasonably and in good faith.
How Employers Try to Defend Against Retaliation Claims
Employers are often advised by legal counsel to create “performance paper trails” to weaken your claim. These tactics include:
- Issuing write-ups after your complaint
- Citing vague “restructuring” reasons for termination
- Claiming the timing of the adverse action was “coincidental”
Experienced retaliation attorneys know how to counter these defenses using timing, comparator evidence (how other employees were treated), and internal communication records.
Why Legal Representation Makes a Critical Difference
Retaliation claims aren’t just emotionally charged, they’re also legally intricate. Success hinges on crafting a compelling narrative, anticipating employer defenses, and leveraging the full scope of the law.
At Levine & Blit, our New York employment attorney experienced in retaliation law can:
- Build a solid evidentiary record
- Preserve your rights at every stage of the process
- Negotiate maximum settlements
- Take your case to trial if necessary
In our experience, victims who hire legal counsel early recover significantly more in damages and are more likely to hold their employers accountable.
How Our NYC Retaliation Attorneys Will Pursue Maximum Compensation for You
At Levine & Blit, we understand that retaliation in the workplace can derail your career, harm your reputation, and cause emotional and financial distress. When you trust us with your case, our experienced New York City retaliation attorneys will pursue every available legal avenue to hold your employer accountable and fight for the maximum compensation you deserve. Whether through settlement, administrative hearing, or civil lawsuit, we take an aggressive, results-driven approach.
Strategic Settlement Negotiations
Many retaliation cases can be resolved before trial through a negotiated settlement. However, not all settlements are created equal. At Levine & Blit, we approach negotiation from a position of strength, not desperation. We thoroughly investigate your employer’s actions, gather compelling evidence, and present a clear legal theory of retaliation supported by documentation and witness testimony. This allows us to demand high-value settlements that include:
- Full back pay and lost benefits
- Front pay or reinstatement, where appropriate
- Emotional distress damages
- Punitive damages in egregious cases
- Legal fees and costs
We never settle low just to move on—we fight for settlements that reflect the true impact of what you’ve suffered.
Administrative Hearings
If your claim is filed with an agency like the EEOC or NYC Commission on Human Rights, and the case proceeds to a hearing, our attorneys will be fully prepared. We represent clients in agency investigations and administrative trials, handling all discovery, motion practice, and evidentiary hearings. We use these proceedings not only to seek damages, but also to hold employers publicly accountable and force systemic change when necessary.
Filing a Civil Lawsuit
When settlement isn’t in your best interest or an agency route is insufficient, Levine & Blit won’t hesitate to file a lawsuit in civil court. Our trial-tested litigators are fearless in front of a judge and jury. We aggressively conduct discovery to uncover internal emails, performance records, and comparators that prove retaliation. We use expert witnesses to quantify your damages and present a compelling case for maximum recovery under powerful statutes like the NYC Human Rights Law, which allows for emotional distress and punitive damages.
At Levine & Blit, we fight tooth and nail to win workplace retaliation cases. Let us fight to get you justice and the full compensation you are legally entitled to.
👉Also Read: Challenging Hiring Bias: How Legal Representation Can Make a Difference
You Don’t Have to Accept Workplace Retaliation in New York
If you believe you’ve been punished for speaking up, taking protected leave, or standing against discrimination, you are not powerless. New York law offers robust tools to protect you.
Whether you’re still employed and noticing early signs of management retaliation, or you’ve already been wrongfully terminated, don’t wait for the situation to worsen. Consult with our experienced retaliation lawyer who understands the legal landscape in New York City and can help you take decisive action.
At Levine & Blit, we represent employees, not companies. We are ready to investigate your claim, advocate fiercely for your rights, and ensure that retaliation does not go unanswered. Schedule a confidential consultation today with our New York City employment retaliation lawyers and take the first step toward holding your employer accountable. Call us at 646-461-6838 or contact us online to set up a confidential consultation.